Old Fenimore Mill Cedar Key
Privately owned vacation rental properties
Navigate forward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.
Navigate backward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.
Stay Near Old Fenimore Mill in Cedar Key, Florida
Learn more about the area's history, attractions, restaurants, and things to do by reading our Old Fenimore Mill Visitor Guide .
If you're searching for Old Fenimore Mill vacation rentals in Cedar Key, Florida, you'll discover one of the area's most unique waterfront destinations. Nestled along Florida's Nature Coast, the historic Old Fenimore Mill district combines Old Florida charm, breathtaking Gulf views, abundant wildlife, and easy access to the laid-back island atmosphere that has made Cedar Key a favorite getaway for generations.
Whether you're planning a romantic weekend, a fishing trip, a kayaking adventure, or a relaxing coastal escape, staying near Old Fenimore Mill places you within walking distance of Cedar Key's historic downtown, locally owned restaurants, art galleries, marinas, and unforgettable sunsets over the Gulf of Mexico.
About Old Fenimore Mill
Old Fenimore Mill is one of Cedar Key's most recognizable historic waterfront landmarks. Originally constructed as part of the island's industrial history, the property has become an iconic part of the Cedar Key skyline and serves as a reminder of the community's rich maritime heritage. Today, visitors staying nearby enjoy peaceful surroundings, scenic waterfront views, and convenient access to everything this charming island has to offer.
Vacation rentals near Old Fenimore Mill range from cozy waterfront cottages to spacious condominiums and private homes. Many feature fully equipped kitchens, comfortable living areas, private balconies or patios, and beautiful views of the Gulf, making them ideal for couples, families, snowbirds, and outdoor enthusiasts.
Community Amenities
Depending on the individual vacation rental, guests staying near Old Fenimore Mill may enjoy amenities such as:
- Waterfront or Gulf-view accommodations
- Private balconies or screened porches
- Fully equipped kitchens
- High-speed Wi-Fi
- Covered parking
- Boat parking (select properties)
- Outdoor grilling areas
- Community swimming pool (select communities)
- Elevator access in condominium buildings
- Easy access to marinas and boat launches
Many properties are designed for travelers looking to enjoy Cedar Key's slower pace while remaining close to local attractions and waterfront activities.
Experience Cedar Key's Natural Beauty
One of the biggest reasons visitors choose to stay near Old Fenimore Mill is the opportunity to experience one of Florida's last authentic fishing villages. Cedar Key is famous for its peaceful atmosphere, incredible birdwatching, fresh seafood, kayaking, fishing, and spectacular Gulf Coast sunsets.
Guests can spend their days exploring tidal marshes by kayak, fishing from local piers, taking eco-tours, visiting nearby islands, biking through town, or simply relaxing while watching dolphins and pelicans along the waterfront.
Restaurants Near Old Fenimore Mill
Tony's Seafood Restaurant
Address: 597 2nd Street, Cedar Key, FL 32625
Known throughout Florida for award-winning clam chowder, fresh Gulf seafood, shrimp baskets, and locally harvested Cedar Key clams.
Steamers Clam Bar & Grill
Address: 420 Dock Street, Cedar Key, FL 32625
A waterfront favorite serving steamed clams, oysters, shrimp, fish sandwiches, and local seafood specialties.
83 West & 29 South at the Beach
Address: 310 Dock Street, Cedar Key, FL 32625
Offers fresh seafood, burgers, sandwiches, cocktails, and outdoor waterfront dining overlooking the Gulf.
The Tipsy Cow Bar & Grill
Address: 575 2nd Street, Cedar Key, FL 32625
A casual restaurant serving burgers, steaks, seafood, wings, and local craft beverages in the heart of downtown.
Annie's Café
Address: 403 2nd Street, Cedar Key, FL 32625
A popular breakfast and lunch café featuring homemade breakfasts, sandwiches, soups, salads, and desserts.
Things to Do Near Old Fenimore Mill
Cedar Key Historical Museum
Learn about Cedar Key's fascinating history through exhibits covering Native American culture, railroad expansion, fishing, and the island's maritime heritage.
Cedar Keys National Wildlife Refuge
Explore protected islands that provide habitat for nesting seabirds, dolphins, sea turtles, and other native wildlife while enjoying excellent photography opportunities.
Cedar Key Fishing Pier
Spend the afternoon fishing, watching boats, photographing sunsets, or simply enjoying the peaceful waterfront atmosphere.
Kayaking the Cedar Key Backwaters
Paddle through quiet marshes, tidal creeks, and mangrove-lined waterways where dolphins, manatees, and countless bird species are frequently spotted.
Cedar Key Arts Center
Browse rotating exhibits featuring local artists, photography, pottery, paintings, and handcrafted works inspired by Florida's Nature Coast.
Why Choose a Vacation Rental Instead of a Hotel?
Vacation rentals near Old Fenimore Mill provide significantly more comfort and flexibility than a traditional hotel room. Guests enjoy fully equipped kitchens, separate bedrooms, spacious living areas, private outdoor spaces, and accommodations that feel like a home away from home.
Whether you're staying for a long weekend or an extended vacation, a Cedar Key vacation rental offers extra space, privacy, and excellent value while allowing you to fully experience the relaxed coastal lifestyle that makes the island so special.
Book Direct Through Emerald Coast By Owner
When you reserve your Old Fenimore Mill vacation rental through Emerald Coast By Owner, you book directly with local owners or professional property managers. Unlike many large travel websites, ECBYO does not charge guest service fees, helping travelers save money while communicating directly with the owner before booking.
Browse available vacation rentals, compare amenities, view detailed photos, and find the perfect place to stay while exploring beautiful Cedar Key.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where is Old Fenimore Mill located?
Old Fenimore Mill is located along the waterfront in Cedar Key, Florida, within easy walking distance of downtown shops, restaurants, marinas, and the Gulf of Mexico.
Are vacation rentals near Old Fenimore Mill waterfront?
Many vacation rentals near Old Fenimore Mill offer waterfront or Gulf-view accommodations, while others are located just a short walk from the shoreline.
What makes Cedar Key different from other Florida beach towns?
Cedar Key is known for its authentic Old Florida charm, working fishing village atmosphere, quiet streets, local seafood, wildlife viewing, and relaxed pace of life instead of large resorts and crowds.
Is Old Fenimore Mill close to downtown Cedar Key?
Yes. Guests staying near Old Fenimore Mill can easily walk to many of Cedar Key's restaurants, shops, galleries, parks, and waterfront attractions.
What outdoor activities are available nearby?
Popular activities include kayaking, fishing, boating, birdwatching, dolphin spotting, shelling, paddleboarding, photography, and exploring the Cedar Keys National Wildlife Refuge.
Are vacation rentals suitable for extended stays?
Yes. Many vacation rentals near Old Fenimore Mill offer full kitchens, laundry facilities, and comfortable living spaces that make them ideal for weekly or monthly stays.
Is Cedar Key a good destination for fishing?
Absolutely. Cedar Key is considered one of Florida's premier fishing destinations, offering excellent inshore, nearshore, and offshore fishing opportunities throughout the year.
Why should I book through Emerald Coast By Owner?
Emerald Coast By Owner allows guests to book directly with owners or property managers while avoiding guest service fees commonly charged by many third-party booking platforms.
